General Info
Arrenello's Pizza Highland sits comfortably in the local food scene as a dependable, down-to-earth pizza restaurant where familiar flavors and a relaxed atmosphere come together. Located at 2556 45th St, Highland, IN 46322, United States, Arrenello's Pizza Highland has become a recognizable stop for anyone craving well-made pizza without the fuss.
Walking in, the experience feels easy and welcoming. The space is set up for dinner service, making it a solid choice for a casual evening meal with family or friends. The wheelchair-accessible entrance ensures everyone can comfortably enjoy the restaurant, and practical amenities like a clean toilet and debit card payment option keep things convenient. Free of charge street parking nearby also makes stopping in stress-free, especially on busy evenings.
The menu keeps the focus where it belongs-on pizza done right. One of the standout choices is the Mushroom Pepper Pizza, which balances earthy mushrooms with the gentle bite of peppers for a flavor that feels both classic and satisfying. For those who prefer something richer, the Deep Dish Cheese Pizza delivers a thick, comforting slice with plenty of melted cheese in every bite. Another popular option, the Cheese and Sausage Deep Dish, adds a savory layer that makes the pizza feel hearty without being overwhelming. Each of these dishes reflects a straightforward approach that prioritizes taste and consistency.
What makes Arrenello's Pizza Highland appealing is how naturally everything comes together. The menu is easy to navigate, the service fits the relaxed vibe, and the food speaks for itself. It’s the kind of place where reviews often highlight reliability-good pizza, familiar flavors, and a setting that doesn’t try too hard to be something it’s not.
For locals exploring dining locations in Highland or visitors looking for a dependable pizza restaurant for dinner, Arrenello's Pizza Highland offers an experience that feels genuine. From the well-loved deep dish options to the practical services that make dining comfortable, this spot continues to earn its place as a go-to neighborhood restaurant.
